W Gary Flamm

From SourceWatch
Jump to: navigation, search

This stub is a work-in-progress by the ScienceCorruption.com journalists's group. We are indexing the millions of documents stored at the San Francisco Uni's Legacy Tobacco Archive [1] With some entries you'll need to go to this site and type into the Search panel a (multi-digit) Bates number. You can search on names for other documents also.     Send any corrections or additions to editor@sciencecorruption.com

This article is part of the Tobacco portal on Sourcewatch funded from 2006 - 2009 by the American Legacy Foundation.

W Gary Flamm used both the common name Gary Flamm, and his more formal W Gary Flamm on many of the tobacco industry archive documents. He was a Tobacco Institute consultant in toxicology thoughout the 1990s and also did consulting work for Philip Morris. [1]

He ran his own consulting business, Flamm Associates which serviced the tobacco and other industries, specialising in the area of Toxicology and Risk Assessment. His qualifications were only a PhD in Medical Biochemistry, but he was an ex-President and Fellow of the American College of Toxicology (ACT), and, at a later date he became the president of the International Society for Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology

His real value to the industry was his status as a former director in the 'Office of Toxicological Services with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.[2]

Documents & Timeline

1959-62 Gary Flamm obtained his Doctor of Philosophy in Biological Chemistry from the University of Cincinnati in Cincinnati Ohio from 1959-1962.


1957-59 He attained a Master of Science degree in Pharmaceutical Chemistry from the University of Cincinnati in Cincinnati, Ohio from 1957-1959,


1953-57 Bachelor of Science degree in Pharmacy, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, Ohio, 1953-1957.


1984 Feb 20-22 The Winter Toxicology Forum meeting at L'Enfant Plaza Hotel, Washington DC. At this time Flamm is Associate Director for Toxicological Sciences Bureau of Foods, FDA. [2]


1987 Toxicology Forum again: Flamm is sill with the FDA in Washington DC. and is doing food colour additive testing. [3]


1988-90 Tobacco Institute Consultant Activity list for these three years.

This is a list of services he has performed for the Tobacco Institute (excludes work for Philip Morris)

Gary Flamm, Ph.D.
Science Regulatory Services International

  1. 11/89 Participated in McGill ETS Symposium.
  2. 4/90 Comments on Chapter 11 of EPA ETS Compendium
  3. 6/90 Letter to the editor of the New York Times regarding article on ETS and cardiovascular disease
  4. 7/90 Testimony on health effects of ETS for Waxman Congressional hearing
  5. 10/90 Participated in ETS risk assessment panel at Society for Risk Analysis Annual Meeting

Current Projects: Comments on EPA ETS risk assessment for SAB review [4]

[Note: The McGill University ETS Symposium held in Montreal in November 1989 was a completely closed conference run by Philip Morris, which was used to train their tame scientists in the problems of passive smoking, and to create a cooperating cohort of corrupt scientists and issues managing executives. It is an indicator of which scientists were knowingly distorting science for the tobacco industry.]



1989 Nov 19 [Wrong date on document] The Environmenal Protection Agency (EPA) was in the process of publicly asserting that second-hand smoke (ETS) was a known carcinogen ("risk assessment").

This is a draft speech script prepared for a media briefing by Dr Don de Bethizy, sentior toxicologist at RJ Reynolds. They have lined up all the industry's favourite scientific touts who are being paid to attack

..."the scientific merit of two EPA draft documents -- the ETS risk assessment and the workplace smoking guide" [which he says] contain many major scientific shortcomings. The time we have today only permits us to scratch the surface.

[In fact they dug out the deepest slime in the pit. Every scientist mentioned here is a long-term tobacco industry science-for-sale entrepreneur or witness for hire.]
Today, you'll hear why
  • Gray Robertson, an internationally regarded expert on indoor air quality, believes the Workplace Smoking Guide is poorly conceived, with conclusions that are ill-considered.
    [Robertson was the owner of ACVA/HBI -- the most corrupt of all the indoor air testing company employed by the tobacco industry. He was one of the industry's main contract lobbyists.]
  • After Gray Robertson, you'll hear from Dr Phil Witorsch, pulmonary physician and a clinical professor of medicine at George Washington University Medical Center. He will detail the specific reasons he believes the EPA has drawn invalid from evidence concerning the relationship between ETS and respiratory diseases in children.
    [He spent most of his time as a tobacco consultant lobbyist, travelling around the world to provide witness services for the tobacco industry in court cases. He was a founding member of the notorious IAPAG (Indoor Air Pollution Advisory Group) which was a 'WhiteCoats' organisation run by tobacco lawyers Covington & Burling.]
  • Dr. John Wesley Clayton, professor emeritus of pharmacology and toxicology at the University of Arizona, and former president of the International Congress of Toxicologists, will discuss the available toxicological data on ETS. None of these data appears in the Risk Assessment. And -- more important -- none supports the contention that ETS is a human carcinogen.
    [Clayon had then been receiving CTR grants for 15 years, and in return, on his retirement, he had become a professional witness who worked extensively for the Tobacco Institute (and probably any other industry with the funds). He was handled by lawyers Shook Hardy & Bacon.]
  • Dr Maurice E LeVois, a highly experienced epidemiologist who has designed large studies for the US government will detail some important omissions in the Risk Assessment. As Dr LeVois will point out,the draft arbitrarily omits important epidemiological, dosimetric, medical and statistical evidence that conflicts with the conclusions reached by the EPA.
    [LeVois was, at various times, the partner of Max Layard and also George Carlo -- both notorious science-for-sale entrepreneurs (Carlo also for the cellphone industry). During the 1990s they worked almost full-time for two industries -- tobacco and dioxin/herbicides -- mainly through infiltrating organisations like Veterams Affairs and conducting their fake studies]
  • Dr. Richard L Tweedie, the dean of information and computing sciences at Bond University in Australia, will present the findings of his own analysis of the epidemiologic studies conducted on ETS. And he will discuss some major differences between his conclusions and those reached by the EPA.
    [Tweedie and his girlfriend (also a long-term tobacco tout) Kerry Mengerson were rewarded with an endowed chair at the University of Colorado]
  • Peter N. Lee, a British statistician whose work is frequently cited by the EPA in the Risk Assessment, will explain why the misclassification adjustment made by the EPA is mathematically incorrect.
    [Lee spent his life as a full-time contractor in statistics to the Tobacco Advisory Committee (TAC) of the UK. He was retained to try to find holes in any adverse scientific finding.]
    Dr William J. Butler, a biostatistician, will focus on the EPA's failure to identify or discuss several important confounding factors that could account for most -- if not all -- of the increased risk noted by the EPA.
    [Butler was a contract scientific lobbyist from the company Failure Anaiysis, Inc. Butler and this company worked extensively for the tobacco industry: he was one of their regular witnesses used with State Assembly hearings. He also spoke at Philip Morris's closed McGill Uni. ETS symposium -- which only enrolled paid industry touts.]
  • Dr Joseph L Fleiss, the head of the division of biostatistics at the Columbia University School of Public Health, will discuss a number of considerations that make meta-analyis an invalid basis for drawing conclusions about ETS.
    [A regular Tobacco Institute consultant and speaker used at fake/closed conferences. (McGill Uni.)]
  • Dr. Paul Switzer, a professor of statistics at Stanford University, will focus on a number of statistical uncertainties, inconsistencies and biases that seriously undermine the scientific credibility of the Risk Assessment.
    [Another regular scientific witness who also played a key role in the loaded McGill University ETS Symposium,]
  • Finally, Dr W Gary Flamm, the president of the International Society for Regulatory Toxicology & Pharmacology, will talk about serious violations of scientific objectivity contained within the .document. [
    The Society was a front for a group of science-for-sale toxicologist who worked for a range of industries with poisoning and polluting problems. Flamm also lectured at McGill.]
[5]

1995 Sept He was billed Philip Morris $1,200 for 8 hours of consulting work with the PM corporate executive scientist Richard Carchman.[3]


1991 July Tobacco Institute - Public Affairs Management Plan:

Scientific Affairs report

An analysis by Drs Gio Gori and Gary Flamm entitled "Mainstream and Environmental Tobacco Smoke" appears in the current issued of Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology.

The article was prepared originally as a submission to the EPA on its ETS risk assessment and was subsquently expanded for publication [6]

Most of the tobacco industry's tame scientists wouldn't have worked with Gori because of his reputation for corrupt science.

References

  1. Tobacco Institute Three Additional Consultant Submissions on the OSHA Request for Information on Indoor Air Quality Memo. March 13, 1992. Bates No. TI01411438
  2. Flamm, WG W. Gary Flamm, PhD Former Director, Office of Toxicological Services U.S. Food and Drug Administration Consultant, Washington, D. C. Resume'. 1990. Lorillard Bates No. 87808940/8951
  3. Flamm WG [ http://legacy.library.ucsf.edu/tid/tuk79e00 Invoice for 950900] Invoice. October 1995. Philip Morris Bates No. 2050763039

<tdo>resource_id=16601 resource_code=flamm_gary search_term=Gary Flamm</tdo>